Local SEO

Do Local Citations Still Matter for Local SEO? What Google Says About Directories

Do business directory listings still help local SEO? What Google says about citations, which listings are worth your time and when directories become link spam.

FindSEO7 min read

Rows of small wooden card catalogue drawers, each with a metal label holder and pull handle, filling the frame of an old library cabinet.

Photo: MarkBuckawicki / Wikimedia Commons (CC0)

In this article
  1. What is a local citation?
  2. How does Google use citations for local rankings?
  3. Why does consistency matter more than volume?
  4. Which listings are worth your time?
  5. When do directory listings become link spam?
  6. How do you clean up your citations?
  7. What should you ask an agency about citations?
  8. A local citations checklist
  9. The bottom line

Local citations still matter, but for accuracy rather than volume. A citation is any mention of your business name, address and phone number on another site, such as a map app, a directory or an industry association. Google says it builds Business Profiles from several sources, including crawled web pages and licensed data from third parties, and that businesses with complete and accurate information are more likely to show up in local results. So the job today is to get a handful of important listings exactly right. Submitting your business to hundreds of low-quality directories adds little, and Google's spam policies list low-quality directory links as an example of link spam.

This guide explains how citations fit into local SEO now, which listings are worth your time and what to ask an agency that offers "citation building".

What is a local citation?

A local citation is any place online that lists your business details. The core of it is often called NAP: name, address and phone number. Many listings add your website, hours, category and photos too.

Citations usually fall into a few groups:

  1. Map and search platforms. Your Google Business Profile, Bing Places for Business and Apple's business listings for Apple Maps.
  2. General business directories. Sites that list businesses of every type by location.
  3. Industry and professional directories. Member lists from trade associations, professional bodies and licensing registers.
  4. Local sources. A chamber of commerce, a council business directory, a local news story or a club you sponsor.
  5. Unstructured mentions. Your business named in an article or blog post, with or without a link.

The first group matters most, because those platforms put your details in front of people searching maps. The rest matter when real customers use them, or when they help keep your details consistent across the web.

How does Google use citations for local rankings?

Google's local ranking help doesn't mention citations by name, and Google doesn't publish how much any one listing counts. What it does say is useful.

Its guide to how Google sources business information lists where the details in a profile come from: publicly available information such as crawled web content (for example a business's official website), licensed data from third parties, users who contribute facts, photos and reviews, including owners who claim their profiles, and information from Google's own interactions with the business. Google also notes that people may see details you didn't add yourself.

Conceptual diagram of where Google gets the details in a Business Profile. You control your Business Profile and your website directly. Users add facts such as addresses and phone numbers, plus photos and reviews. Licensed data from third parties and Google's own interactions with the business come from elsewhere. The takeaway: keep every source saying the same thing, because Google doesn't publish how it weighs them. Source: Google Business Profile Help.
Your profile and your website are the two sources you fully control. Conceptual, not data.

Then there's ranking. Google's tips to improve your local ranking say local results are mainly based on relevance, distance and prominence. Prominence is how well known a business is, and Google says it draws on information such as how many websites link to your business and how many reviews you have. The same page says businesses with complete and accurate information are more likely to show up, and that there's no way to request or pay for a better local ranking.

Put together, citations help in two ways. They're one of the places Google can confirm your details, and a listing on a site that people genuinely use can be part of what makes a business well known. Our guide to how Google ranks local results covers relevance, distance and prominence in more detail, including what decides the local pack.

Why does consistency matter more than volume?

Because Google tells you to be consistent. Its guidelines for representing your business ask businesses to represent themselves "as it's consistently represented and recognized in the real world across signage, stationery, and other branding." The business name should match the name used on your storefront, website and stationery. The address or service area should be accurate and precise. And there should be only one profile per business, because duplicates can cause problems with how your information displays on Google Maps and Search.

The same logic applies off Google. If an old directory still shows the address you left three years ago, or a phone number you no longer answer, customers can find it, and it sits among the public web content Google reads. Clean data is also easier to keep clean: when every listing copies one master record, a change of address or number takes an afternoon, not a month of detective work.

A round white ceramic house sign reading Little Vic and the number 13, with painted flowers at the bottom, fixed to a red brick wall.
Google asks for an accurate, precise address that matches how your business appears in the real world. Photo: Michael Garlick, CC BY-SA 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons.

Volume is a different matter. Nothing in Google's guidance suggests that hundreds of listings beat a few accurate ones, and the spam policies point the other way.

Which listings are worth your time?

Work through them in this order:

  1. Your Google Business Profile. Verify your business and complete every field that applies. If you have several sites, our guide to managing Business Profiles for multiple locations covers the extra steps, and businesses that visit customers should read our guide to service-area Business Profiles.
  2. Your own website. Show the same name, address and phone number on your contact page and anywhere else they appear. Add LocalBusiness structured data, which lets you tell Google about details such as opening hours and departments. Schema.org's sameAs property can point to profiles that clearly identify your business. Our schema generator builds the markup, and the Academy lesson on structured data basics explains how it works.
  3. Bing and Apple. Claim your listing in Bing Places for Business, which controls how you appear in Bing search and Bing Maps, and in Apple Business, which manages your place card on Apple Maps. Give both exactly the same details as your Google profile.
  4. Industry and local bodies that customers use. A listing with your trade association, professional body or chamber of commerce is useful if people actually look there. The test is simple: would a customer find you through this page?
  5. Everything else. Low priority. Fix them if they're wrong, but don't chase them.
Conceptual priority list of business listings. Do first: Google Business Profile, verified and complete, and your own website with the same name, address and phone wherever they appear plus LocalBusiness markup. Do next: Bing Places for Business and Apple Business. Worth it if customers use them: industry and professional bodies and local organisations such as a chamber of commerce. Skip: bulk submissions to hundreds of low-quality directories and listings sold for the link without rel sponsored or nofollow. Source: Google Business Profile Help, Google Search Central spam policies, Bing Places and Apple Business.
Accuracy on a few listings beats volume on many. Conceptual, not data.

When the point is the link rather than the listing. Google's spam policies define link spam as creating links primarily to manipulate rankings, and "low-quality directory or bookmark site links" are one of the examples. Bing's webmaster guidelines take the same line on link schemes, including link buying and link spamming.

Paying for a listing isn't the problem in itself. Google says buying links for advertising is a normal part of the web, as long as the links are qualified. Its guide to qualifying outbound links asks sites to mark paid placements with rel="sponsored", with nofollow still acceptable. So a paid listing in a genuine directory is fine if you're paying for the customers it sends. A package that sells you hundreds of backlinks from directories nobody visits is the kind of thing the policy describes. Our guides to whether link building is still worth it and Google's spam policies cover the wider rules.

Two old telephone directories, volumes A to K and L to Z, lying side by side on a wooden table, their covers illustrated with ink sketches of city buildings.
Directories started as books people used to find a business. That's still the test of whether a listing is worth having. Photo: Mapmark, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons.
A listing worth having A red flag
Real people use it to find businesses like yours Nobody visits it except to add listings
It checks or edits what gets listed Anyone can add anything, instantly
It's relevant to your industry or area It lists every type of business everywhere
Paid placements are clearly labelled It sells "do-follow links" or "link juice"
You keep the login and can edit your details Someone else controls the listing for you

How do you clean up your citations?

A one-off clean-up usually follows the same order:

  1. Write one master record. Your real-world business name, full address, main phone number and website URL, exactly as you want them shown.
  2. Fix and verify your Google Business Profile so it matches the record.
  3. Match your website, then add or update your LocalBusiness markup. Our guide to adding LocalBusiness schema markup walks through the JSON-LD.
  4. Claim Bing Places and Apple Business and update them to match.
  5. Fix or report duplicates and outdated details on any directory where you find them.
  6. Add a few relevant listings from industry and local bodies, and record every login in one place you control.
Conceptual six-step order for cleaning up local citations: write one master record of your name, address, phone and website; fix and verify your Google Business Profile; match your website and add LocalBusiness structured data; claim Bing Places and Apple Business; fix or report duplicates and old details on directories; then add a few relevant industry and local listings and record every login. After any move, rebrand or new number, update the master record and then every listing in the same order. Source: Google Business Profile Help and Google Search Central.
Fix the sources that feed the most places first, then work outwards.

When you move, rebrand or change your number, repeat the same order, and build the update into your moving checklist so old details don't linger.

What should you ask an agency about citations?

Some agencies sell citation building as a monthly line item. Ask:

  1. Which listings will you create or fix, and why each one? A good answer names specific platforms and bodies relevant to your industry and area.
  2. Who will own the logins? You should. Our guide to what an SEO contract should include covers account ownership.
  3. How will you handle duplicates and old addresses?
  4. Are any listings paid, and are those links marked as sponsored?
  5. How will you measure the result? Look for Business Profile calls, direction requests and website visits in your monthly SEO report, not a count of listings.

A large, fixed number of new directory listings each month is a reason to ask more questions. For more interview questions, see what to ask an SEO agency before you hire.

A local citations checklist

  • One master record of business name, address, phone number and website.
  • Google Business Profile verified, complete and matching the record.
  • Only one Business Profile per business or location.
  • Website shows the same details, with LocalBusiness structured data.
  • Bing Places and Apple Business claimed and matching.
  • Duplicates and old addresses or numbers fixed or reported.
  • Industry and local listings limited to ones customers actually use.
  • No bulk directory packages or unlabelled paid links.
  • Every login recorded and owned by the business.
  • Listings updated in the same order after any move or rebrand.

The bottom line

Citations haven't stopped mattering. They've stopped being a numbers game. Google wants accurate, consistent business details and reads them from several sources, so get your Business Profile, website, Bing and Apple listings exactly right, then add the few industry and local listings your customers actually use. Skip the bulk directory packages. If you'd like help, compare local SEO agencies, browse local SEO specialists in Melbourne or SEO agencies across Australia, check how strong competing pages are with the page authority checker, or get matched with an agency that fits your brief.

FAQs

What is a local citation in SEO?

A local citation is any online mention of your business name, address and phone number, such as a Google Business Profile, a directory listing, an industry association's member page or a local news story. Many listings also include your website, hours and category.

Do citations still help local rankings?

They help mainly through accuracy. Google says it builds Business Profiles from sources including crawled web content and licensed third-party data, and that complete, accurate information makes a business more likely to show up. Google doesn't publish how much any single listing counts.

How many directory listings does my business need?

There's no target number in Google's guidance. Get your Google Business Profile, website, Bing Places and Apple Business listings right first, then add the industry and local listings your customers actually use.

Can directory links hurt my site?

They can if they're there to manipulate rankings. Google's spam policies list low-quality directory or bookmark site links as an example of link spam. Paid listings are fine when the directory marks the links as sponsored or nofollow.

What should I do with citations after I move?

Update your master record first, then your Google Business Profile and website, then Bing Places and Apple Business, then any directories that show the old address. Report duplicates rather than leaving two versions live.

Sources

Ready for help with SEO?

Compare SEO-only agencies near you, with client reviews checked by a person, or tell us what you need and get matched.

Local SEO

How to Set Up a Google Business Profile

Add or claim your listing, complete the verification method Google offers, and fill in accurate hours, photos and contact details for Search and Maps.

FindSEO5 min read